Question about whether or not to leave a bad review

Hi everyone! I’m new to the forum, but I’ve used TH for a few years and have loved it overall. Recently, I encountered a sitter who wasn’t terrible but also was not good. I had a lot of questions about the quality of care she gave my cat and whether she paid attention to the guide. She was free-feeding my cat, who is on a diet; all her normal spots were deshelved when we got home, and my cat seemed lonely and desperate for attention when we returned. On top of that, her communication was lacking, which caused us a great deal of anxiety while we were gone. The house was fine when we returned, and my cat was okay, so that’s good. The sitter is a single mom of a young child who came along on the sit. With the understanding that being a single mom is already difficult, I don’t want to besmirch this sitter’s reputation if this was a one-off. I’m thinking of simply not leaving a review at all. Any similar experiences or recommendations?

You don’t want to besmirch the reputation of a subpar sitter, so they can go on and do similar things to other pets and hosts?

Instead, how about considering what you wish you’d known before having this sitter sit? Then review factually?

Hi @DRlauraD and welcome to the Forum.

Sorry to read that things didn’t go as they should have but it’s good that you’ve come to the Forum, where experienced members, like @Maggie8K , can give you helpful feedback.

She had excellent reviews prior to our sit. I absolutely want to make sure that no one has a similar experience. But I question my experience… was I too demanding? Too untrusting? I’ve been really spoiled by THs in the past—I’ve only ever had stellar sitters, and this recent experience is so confusing.

These elements all sound like a subpar sitter, not unreasonable expectations.

Thank you for saying that. I felt a little gaslit by my interactions with her when I asked directly for more communication and accountability and she responded with excuses

Her prior reviews and ratings may have been from people like you who didn’t want to taint the rating of a single mom. Well, if you don’t give a factual review, you’ll just push the problem to the next HO. Not good.

Deduct a * or 2 where deserved and explain why.

Not following the cats proper diet is a major issue. Please review honestly. Whether she is a single mom or not is irrelevant, either she can handle the proper care of the pets or she shouldn’t be sitting.

The only fact you’ve shared is that her communication was lacking. Your other “lot of questions” and “seemed lonely” are not objective facts. Review what you know and leave your suspicions aside unless you have more evidence the sit was mishandled. Making unsubstantiated accusations in a review reflects poorly on the writer and leaves them open to being negated by a well written response.

Most people will say leave honest review because they want to know thiese things!

I appreciate your empathy towards her being a single mom and recognizing she might have had her hands full. However, insufficient communication and overfeeding the cat are not teensy complaints. The very basics of house and pet sitting requires making sure to communicate frequently enough (and being mature/responsible enough to accept responsibility when asked about such a fundamental expectation on THS) and following pet owner’s instructions for feeding and other care. If I messed up on either of these counts, I would feel terrible and express my embarrassment and regret that I fell short of what was agreed upon. I think you can dock her a star on “Happy pets” and “Reliability” and “Communication” with a clear conscience. This is not a character assassination but a fair assessment. You can give her, say, four stars overall and give credit where credit’s due, such as “She arrived on time and left the house in good order” if that’s the case. Maybe a sandwich approach: point out what you were happy with, mention what fell short of your expectations/agreement, then end with another positive. I’ve seen reviews of sitters that say “___ was easy to talk with and a very nice person” but also “I think if they work on communicating better” or whatever fits “they will become the kind of sitter I would wholeheartedly recommend.” If worded kindly, hopefully this sitter will take your criticisms as things to improve on.

Taking care of only one cat is considered an easy sit and there should be no excuse for inadequate care. Not feeding properly is a big deal. Ignoring an animal as you eluded to is abusive in my eyes. If she has her hands full being a mom as you state, then she should not take on the responsibility of caring for pets if she can’t give them appropriate care. She’s a big girl and needs to take responsibility for her actions which include choosing to take care of pets. How old is the child? Is she teaching her to ignore the pet and they go off and do their own thing? Or to not have respect for the cat’s space and beds and toys. This is not a 5 star sit and giving her that is a disservice. You need to leave a review. Start with the positives if there are any. Mention the parts that were not satisfactory. You may be doing her a favor and she needs to reflect and reevaluate things. Children go through different stages and this may not be a good time for her to continue to pet sit. She made need a break. Are they nomads or have a home to return to? Being a nomad with a young child may need reflection.

Can I just ask, how do you know that this sitter was free-feeding the cat? Is this based on something you observed, or an assumption based on the amount of food remaining or the cat’s condition on your return?

I’m also not sure what you mean when you say your cat’s normal spots were ‘deshelved’? Could you elaborate on that?

Did you provide a comprehensive welcome guide, and did it specify feeding quantities, meal times and particular routines? Likewise, did you specify your update requirements in the WG, as well as verbally, and did you contact the sitter to request more frequent updates when communication was lacking?

I’m just wondering whether the sitter failed to follow specific instructions or whether the care simply didn’t meet the quality you’d hoped for or expected.

Communication before and during sits is a shared responsibility and, quite often on these boards, we read about unmet expectations where it would be useful to understand how clearly those expectations were communicated by both parties.

I’m not asking these questions to apportion blame or cause offence, but to help you work out what went wrong and what you might do to help ensure a better experience in future.

What does " normal spots were deshelved" mean?

I wondered that. Did the cat sleep on shelves where the young child could reach :thinking:

It is not about leaving a “bad” review. It is about leaving an honest one.

You can concurrently note the positives of her stay and care alongside the negative ones.

As long as the points you note are objective, honest and non-emotional, you should submit a review. Not doing is both irresponsible to yourself, this sitter and all potential hosts.

The fact that she is a single mom is irrelevant (unless she broughther child without asking or letting you know which doesn’t seem to be the case ?).

Finally, consider the possibility that her previous reviews were 5* because previous hosts approached from the same place - fear of impact on the sitter’s future sitting possibilities. The previous host’s experiences may have been similar to yours…and because they weren’t honest, you and your kitty suffered.

Agreed you need to state facts, not opinions.

Things like “the cat seemed lonely” cannot be proven and “needed attention” and doesn’t prove much of anything. Pets get lonely for their owners, even when cared for.

If your Welcome Guide instructions were not followed or the house was not as clean as when you left it, state the facts.

Totally agree, stick to facts.

I understand the internal conflict, but you should still leave an honest, objective review.

It is natural to feel empathy for a single mother balancing a child and a sit. However, understanding someone’s personal circumstances shouldn’t mean compromising pet safety or home care standards. When a sitter free-feeds a cat on a strict diet, fails to maintain requested communication, and leaves pet areas untidy, those are clear, objective failures to meet the job’s baseline responsibilities.

The entire THS ecosystem relies on accurate feedback to function safely. When people withhold the truth or leave five stars out of guilt, they pass those same risks on to the next homeowner, and ultimately harm the pets who rely on strict care routines. Leaving a calm, factual review (e.g., noting the feeding deviations, communication gaps, and cleanliness issues without personal attacks) isn’t being “mean” or punishing her. It is providing essential data that keeps the platform honest, safe, and accountable for everyone. I would bet her previous glowing reviews were from people who also felt guilty being honest. Can we please normalize being honest?

I think they meant to say “disheveled”, aka messy.

I think the first step for OP is to get away from thinking about leaving a ‘bad’ review, and simply to leave the review of what happened. In your shoes, I would knock off a star (or two) for communication*, since you made a request for more and it was received poorly. Mention the change in feeding type. I think it’s important to note the things that went well - clean house on return. For things you suspect but don’t know, well, you can damn with faint praise on those items, which I think is a fair way to handle it.

Most importantly - it’s one sit, the cat is ultimately fine, everyone got through it! No need to overstate how great it was, but also it doesn’t need to be super harsh. Think about what you might want to ask during your next sit to get a better fit. And give that cat all the snoodles they missed while you were gone!

*I hate that there is still no sitter category for Communication! Reliable is probably the one I’d use.