What would you do if a dog or cat you were sitting for ran off and you couldn't find them?

We were on a recent month long sit. The Home host had told me the dog had good recall and it was ok to let him off his leash - Pointing out a regular spot they go for exercise - A large expanse of grass surrounded by forest.

And so it was - every day for two weeks we went to the spot - The dog running ahead then me calling when I thought he was far enough and he would come bounding back to my side.

Until the first day of the third week.

We went out as usual, the dog was quite a distance ahead when he suddenly stopped - Ears went up, one front leg raised and he stared into the forest. He stood there statue -like for probably thirty seconds totally ignoring my calls then, without warning headed straight for the forest!

The feeling in the pit of your stomach is hard to describe. The phone call I would have to make to the home host was all I could think of. I headed into the forest calling his name but there was no sight of him. I swear you could actually see my heart pounding!

There was no one around to ask and I had no phone on me to call for assistance - After mulling over my predicament I decided my best option would be to hang around and keep calling which is what I did

Low and behold, around 10 minutes later ( which felt like a lifetime) I heard the scamper of doggy feet and out of the trees came the accused - covered head to paw in thick mud and looking very sorry for himself - I have never been so relieved.

For the next two weeks he stayed on leash at all times!

8 Likes

@Colin we had EXACTLY the same happen to us on the South Downs in Sussex with a “Highly Trained” Springer (ex army sniffer dog) we were 6 weeks into a 3 month sit.

All the calling in the world couldn’t compete with deer smells, our feelings were identical to yours … Woody came back, eventually.

The leash was our friend for the duration of that sit, and every sit since …

Probably not Woody’s though :dog: :wink: .

1 Like

@anon4168721 I love your response as I thought the same just that I would add at the end …while having a stiff drink!

1 Like

Ours was a Springer too!

Why am I not surprised @Colin? … Having been owned by six of these adorable creatures I know how their noses rule, making them suffer from selective hearing, :rofl: :dog:

I’ve finally followed through on something I learned about on the forum. I ordered tags to take with me on sits. After discussing it with owners, I will add my tag to the pet’s collar, if we think it’s appropriate. What comes to mind for me is maybe the supposedly indoor cats who are known escape artists, or may more likely be with sitters. I’m not one to walk a dog off-leash, so that would be less of an issue, but maybe still useful.

I ordered these through Amazon, and had a good allowance for characters inscribed on both sides. These are just over 1" in size, but they had a range of sizes. I added my country as my preferred sits outside of Canada are in Mexico and many people there have phone plans that cover Canada. In hindsight I should have perhaps added my country code, but no doubt these will be better than only the owner’s tag, if the owner is not reachable for some reason.

5 Likes

Perfect! We also sat a couple of dogs that were running off all the time (but this is what they did with their owners and we were instructed to let them off the leash). This will be helpful if we should be in that situation again. PS: We would probably go with an Apple AirTag or similar products, not sure which product is the best.

We are always a little cautious about letting any pets outside without a leash. There’s a place close to home that’s fenced, it often it’s a bit crowded. We just finishing up our longest sit, and finally found a park large enough, where she can roam without being tethered to us. She did very well, for the most part, but we are still overly attentive, when she’s free to amble on her own. Her recall was very good in certain areas of the park, and when the dog crowds thickened, we put her back on leash.


We have had a couple of animal lost situations on different sits, first one was in the UK with two German Shorthair hunting dogs. They had GPS collars and we were required to take them to a large park area about 1/2 mile from the house and let them run in the forest off lead - we were told they had good recall, but that turned out to be true for the owners but not us. We were well briefed on the equipment and software on our phones but on the day they decided to run further (probably chasing squirrels) than usual we discovered that the collars worked but not well enough to give us a location quick enough. They were running so fast in the forest that by the time the signal caught up to our phones, they were probably 1/4 mile away from the spot the map showed. (At that time, GPS tracking was useless, but we have now experienced newer better technology that is more accurate). One dog came back after about 1/2 hour and found us, the other continued to be missing. After scouring the forest trails and meadows and talking with other dog owners (and being massively apprehensive at the possibilities) we found a lady who knew ‘our dogs’ and saw the lost dog and knew he was stressed, put a leash on him and searched the trails to find us. So, our lesson with this experience was to not accept dog sits where the owner insists that the dogs go off lead outside of a fenced area or dog park. Recall is not the same for sitters as it is for owners. When a dog owners tells us we can take the dog off lead if we want, we always tell them that we do not feel comfortable doing that while we are the responsible party for those dogs.

Our second lost pet was on a 80 acre ranch (off the grid - mountains, forest, predators) when the cat disappeared about a week into our sit. After a day of calling and looking, we contacted the owners and they said it wasn’t uncommon when there were others caring for the cat and not to worry - he would come back. He had not returned when the owners got home a week later and they were sure he would come home now that they were home. We felt terrible leaving without knowing where he was but the owners were ok with it. We kept in touch and after 2 weeks more they had given up and feared the worst, but he then showed up - apparently none the worse for wear! I think the lesson here and in other situations is to communicate quickly with the owners (if possible) about any situation that concerns you (and discuss how they want you to handle emergency type situations while their home and pets are in your care.).

4 Likes

A few years back, my friend’s cat came to stay with me whilst they were away. Obviously I planned to keep him inside for the duration as I’m not local to his normal stomping grounds.

He disappeared. I was 99% certain he hadnt got out through a door or window… and yet he had completely vanished. I looked in every room of the house. And then again, making sure to shut the door between searches, so he wasnt sneaking out behind my back. I started to doubt myself, maybe I had left a door open… Argh! How would I tell my friend I had lost her cat???

I eventually found him sleeping on a pile of plates at the back of a corner kitchen cupboard. He’d opened it himself and the door swung shut so I never realised it had been opened. And obviously he’d ignored all my calls! I closed the door and left him to come out in his own good time :smiley:

2 Likes

Off we went, first thing this morning, to woods that we had not visited before. The dog that we were looking after was off lead, but by our side. That is, until he encountered a large breed of dog and shot off.
After a while we split up and I eventually found the dog.
However, I had lost Mr Itchyfeet!
The woods were dark with narrow winding steps and he couldn’t find his way, despite us ringing each other. We agreed by phone that I and dog would meet, hopefully, in a coffee shop in town.
Mr Itchyfeet eventually walked down a long narrow path, marked Private which led into a large manicured garden. He walked through the grounds without being arrested and we were all reunited.
I will be putting leads on both of them in future.

3 Likes

We had a runaway just recently , not on a THS sit, going for a walk through a large wooded area the dog was happily chasing squirrels and anything else but would come back when called. Then she just disappeared! My partner and I split up and walked different directions, spoke to lots of other dog walkers to please keep an eye out for her and shared contact details with them. After about an hour I got a call she had been seen and eventually got her back only 100m from where we last saw her! The people who had her said they would have called the number on the collar ( owners) but it was rusted over. I was just getting to the point of we will have to call them myself by then. We did tell them once she was back and they were very appreciative of us being honest about it and asked if we had any recommendations for future sitters in our handover so that was good. Scariest hour ever and I think I walked nearly 15k that day !

2 Likes

This is why we are uncomfortable letting dogs off leash. You just never know when they’ll see something fun to chase and take off. Bad enough if it’s our own pet, but someone else’s? Yikes!

1 Like

I probably wont sit for an outdoor cat again. That is very stressful.

Just had this experience as we finished our sit yesterday. The indoor / outdoor cat we had been looking after is supposed to be kept in a specific room when ever we went out . We did this all through the sit with no issues , coaxing her indoors with treats before we went out anywhere.

So to the day of our early morning departure when we did not let the cat out as usual in the morning. As we went to pack up the car and opened the door just a crack, she rushed past us and sneaked out and so now we can’t get her back indoors and we have to leave !! Not the way that we wanted to end the sit with the cat missing !!

We messaged the owners who were on their way home and we were very relieved when they told us she was waiting for them by the door when they arrived not long after we had left . They also said that she often does this to them .:sweat_smile:

5 Likes

I have two indoor/outdoor cats. They rarely leave the general vicinity of my home. But once, about 4 years ago, one of them went missing on a Saturday, Monday was a holiday. On Tuesday I went to the animal control shelter and there he was. But that’s. In, in the eight years Ive had him and the four years the other cat, that’s the only time they’ve gone missing. But, with every sitter I let them know that I know the risks of having indoor/outdoor cats and if either of them were to go missing, I would in no way hold them responsible.

As a sitter of indoor/outdoor cats, I have the same conversation with the owners. And, when a listing says a cat can be outside ‘with. Supervision’, I scroll right past. If a cat is outside and decides to go, it’s going to go. Expecting human ‘supervision’ to prevent that is an risk I’m not willing to take.

Recently I was sitting for two indoor/outdoor cats in London. I arrived the evening before the owners left, the morning of their departure, they informed me that one of the cats had not returned and she’d not done that before. We all assumed she’d likely turn up that afternoon. They left on their vacation and I stayed at the house all that day and the next, in hopes she would turn up. That silly cat stayed gone six days and when she strolled back it was like she’d just left. I was very relieved that she left while her owners were still there. And, especially now, I’m sure to specifically discuss this eventuality with any cat owners I sit for.

5 Likes

I believe our comfort level with indoor/outdoor kitties has changed over the last year. I thought we would be limiting ourselves to fewer sitting options with strictly indoor cats, but we’ve had no problem securing sits, whenever we seek one. So for now, we will continue to search for the cuddly indoor kitties, who ‘prefer’ our company, rather than the outside critters who roam the neighborhood. We are more than happy to take leash trained kitties outside, and have encountered more of them recently :heart_eyes_cat:


7 Likes

@Joanne beautiful photos, they are adorable!
:cat::smiling_face_with_three_hearts:

1 Like

This just happened to me for the first time. When I met the owner and dog to go over the routine, the owner showed me how she leaves the sliding door partly open so the dog could come and go from the back garden, which is only partially fenced. I asked if the dog would run off, and the owner said no, but check on her every so often. I was also advised that I did not need to keep the dog on a leash, unless we were walking on a busy road or past a house that has a lot of feral cats. Out of caution and wisdom, I DID keep the dog on a leash, except when we were actively playing fetch with the ball in an area where it would have been difficult to run away from. And I DID keep an eye on the dog while the door was open. I made a cup of tea, and the dog was at my feet as I poured it. In the five minutes between when I poured the tea and set it down on the coffeetable, I was about to sit on the couch, and I looked around for the dog who I thought would sit on the couch with me, and she’d vanished.
I went outside and called for her, to no avail. This was a hillside on a treeless coast, and I could see all around. The dog I was told would not run off had indeed run off. I wasn’t sure if I should go look for her or stay home in case she returned. I walked to the end of the road where two neighbor dogs she plays with live—both look a lot like her. The first dog came to my call, and then I realized it was not the right dog. Then the second dog came to my call, still not the right one! I called and called, and she did not return. I called a friend who lives nearby, and he said he would walk around and look for her while I stayed at the house, in case she returned. We did not find her. I went walking all over, retracing the steps of our morning walk, did not find her. I drove up onto the main road and all over the village, no sign of her. At this point I’d covered the entire valley, and there was no place to hide. I talked to neighbors, nobody had seen her. One told me she runs off a lot—funny, the owner told me she didn’t! That neighbor suggested I wait till dark before I call the owner, so as not to upset her prematurely. Knowing what I know about dogs, they will usually return for supper.
So I waited and called, waited and called, talked to more neighbors, looked. As the sun was setting, I figured I’d better call the owner—maybe there’s a friendly house she’d gone to, or maybe she could check or post on the local WhatsApp group (which I’m not on, not being local). Owner freaked out, and got angry that I hadn’t called her right away. She said whenever the dog runs away, she’s able to find her if she looks for her right away, but if it’s been a few hours, there’s no chance of finding her. ??? The dog I’d been assured wouldn’t run away had run away several times??? And there’s a pattern that I wasn’t told when I asked IF THE DOG MIGHT RUN AWAY?! There were specific people to call, which the owner hadn’t told me about, when I asked if she might run away?
Owner called one of those specific people, and that person drove me around to the various places where the dog might be. Dog was not in any of those places. Owner called me a few more times to freak out and say, if only you’d called me right away…. Her friend told me about all the times the dog had run away, but also made me feel bad that I’d lost her—she’s never been missing THIS long (three hours)!! Finally, we returned to the house, and the dog was there waiting for me. Just as my instinct had told me—she’d be back by dark. I just made the mistake of alerting the owner a tiny bit too early.
Lessons learned? 1) Ask the owner exactly what to do and who to call if the dog runs away. If the owner deflects and says the dog doesn’t run away, still ask for an exact protocol. 2) Trust an instinct. The dog returned by dark, just as my gut told me she would.
I’m curious what others think: if a dog disappears from home, is it best to call the owner immediately, or look/give it time, then call if it hasn’t returned by dark/a reasonable time?

3 Likes

I am sorry to hear that. Whether to contact the hosts right away or not I think depends on so many individual factors. Last year we had a dog run off–she was psycho for cats, one ran right in front of us that I didn’t have time to see, and she pulled on me so hard she knocked me down–first pet-sitting injury I had in over 10 years of sitting. The leash came out of my hand when I fell and she took off.

The reason we were so concerned is because the hosts said she had no sense for cars, and would likely get hit by one if she was ever loose by the highway that runs through the town, which was only a few blocks away from their home. People drive extremely fast on this road. We looked for her for a few minutes but she really took off and she could have gone in so many directions.

So in this instance, I knew it was best to call them right away and let them know what happened…they either had a Whatsapp chat or a Facebook page for local residents where they alerted the neighbors to keep an eye out for her. Shortly after, one of the neighbors found her…she was actually only up about a street over–she must have done a whole loop of the neighborhood based on the original direction in which she ran– and I am sure she would have made her way back to the house; but contacting them probably brought her back a lot sooner.

How you reacted is understandable. The only reason I may have reached out to the host right away is because she claimed he never ran off–you obviously came to find out that wasn’t true, but at the time was not aware. I don’t think it was a matter of a clear right and wrong way to approach it, especially if you were not given explicit instructions on how to handle the situation. And you are right, it is definitely a good thing to ask the host directly about this and how they want it handled.

Glad he came back! I am sure that was very stressful

1 Like