I’m sorry you’ve experienced this!!
-
Please do raise a member dispute, as others have mentioned. (@Silversitters recently created a detailed post about how to navigate this process)
-
One bad review isn’t a death sentence. Yes, it may impact some applicants, but as @Garfield pointed out, it probably works in your favor that she gave 1 rather than a more balanced 2-3 stars as it seems to reflect more on her than on you.
-
Leave a just-the-facts, unemotional response to her review. This will be important, and you’ve only got one shot at it. Feel free to post your draft here if you’d like feedback before submitting it.
It’s great that you’ve already got another sitter lined up for the next one – and a repeat sitter at that, which is a good sign to future applicants! If you’re really serious about burying the review and re-building your stars, you might consider reaching out to sitters who have favorited your listing, telling them you’re interested in taking a short vacation for ~x number of days, and ask if there are dates when they may want to come for a sit. It might lead to nothing (don’t take declines personally – most invites are declined), or it might lead to a great connection. #whoknows