Where is this? I didn’t see anything?
I think there is space for both. Having the feedback section is needed so users can discuss ideas. But I think a place where ONLY admins can create threads and post updates, which won’t be buried in the middle of a ton of other threads, which can be a source of truth, would be really helpful. Rather than rehashing the review system for the 3498234th time, we could refer to the “Review System Improvements” thread that an admin started which could, IMO, could work something like this:
Initial post
- Summary of the users concerns
- Estimated effort (high, medium, low)
- Priority (high, medium, low)
- Current status (doing user research, in development, in testing, etc)
- Estimated completion date (a VERY conservative delivery estimate so people know what to have in mind other than NOW)
- Potential changes - high level summary of the changes you are considering, based on user input
Updates could be along the lines of:
Currently conducting user interviews to seek feedback and ideas. If you’re interested in participating, respond with a thumbs up to this post.
or
User interviews completed with the following highlights:
1
2
3
Please discuss in this thread: and link to a thread in the feedback section where users can discuss what you heard and where users in the future can go to read past discussions vs weeding through a ton of other threads on the topic.
or
Due to the scope of the change needed, we’ve decided to break the feature into stages. Stage 1 of development has started. Deliverables for this stage include
a
b
c
We estimate it will take x-y weeks for development and testing. If you would be willing to beta test, please respond with a thumbs up to this post.
Please discuss the deliverables for this stage in this thread:
I know that this is a bit more work, but it shouldn’t be a TON, and it might help wrangle some of the discussion and keep it more organized. It would also make it really easy to refer new people who raise old issues to specific threads addressing those issues without the mega threads. It would also give users who are antsy for things to happen immediately a timeline to have in their heads that’s more realistic and maybe get them off your back about why things aren’t happening this second.
FWIW, these are the types of updates I send to MY clients on a regular basis to keep them off MY back when they start getting all up in my space about progress because they have no idea how long development takes.
It takes a few minutes to type them up but saves me HOURS each week of having to wrangle clients. “Oh, that’s on friday’s update, take a look: (link to update)”