Dr. Jekyll and Mr Hyde kind of story

Hi everyone, I hope you are all having great experiences surrounded by lots of furry lovely pals. This is my first time posting and I would like to know your opinion. It is a long story but I hope you can make it to the end, please.

4 days ago my husband and I finished our first 21-day stay taking care of three beautiful, giant Bernese Mountain dogs + three cats with whom we made a wonderful connection. Everything was going “well,” in fact we left the house with a great feeling of victory and pride in having had a nice experience, even though there were details that were not optimal from the beginning, but that, good or bad, we knew how to overcome so that there was no reason to ruin the experience.

We agreed with the owner to arrive a day early so that she could show us the dynamics with the 3 dogs, the 3 cats, the house and her lots of plants. That day the owner was very busy, and there was only time to walk the dogs and see how to feed them. That night she let us stay in the basement, which she regularly uses for Airbnb visitors.

The next morning, before she left, I asked her to show me the top floor to see where we would be staying and that’s when we found out that we had to sleep with all the pets. On top of that, there wasn’t a single space to put our stuff. I asked her if we could sleep in the basement and she said no, because the pets were used to having company. This was never mentioned in the welcome guide (to sleep with them) and it will surprise us a lot. We slept in her room but the cats didn´t let us sleep, so they had to sleep on the other room.

Also I asked her if we could keep our stuff in the basement because there wasn’t room available for us and she said yes, that we could use the whole house without a problem.

All of this is important to mention in order to understand the end of the story.

Once she left, we had to vacuum the couches and cushions to feel comfortable sitting there. the smell was bad and they were not clean at all, the vacuum cleaner container ended up full of hair and dirt.

When we checked the fridge to make a bigger space, we found a lot of rotten food from the year 2022, 2023 even with mold, also rotten fruits and vegetables that we had to throw away.

The next day the hot water stopped running and the kitchen sink got clogged. We told her immediately and her response was not pleasant, she said that this was very strange, that it had never happened before, as if we had caused it. At least she was responsible and called some technicians to show up the next day.

The breakdowns were serious, it took 2 days or so for the workers to be able to fix them. They had to replace several parts of the heater that was from the 90s. On the other hand, the pipes were so clogged with garbage that they needed special tools and many hours to unclog it.

Once this was sorted out, everything went very well. The dogs got used to us and we got into a pretty good routine, really, I have no complaints about pets.

Another day, with a rather lascivious tone in her message, she told us that a neighbor had written to her that the dogs were barking, asking why we had them outside in so much heat (it was cloudy that day). This started to give me red signals, because her tone and her way of communicating through whatsapp was kind of aggressive. That morning, after feeding them, and when the weather was mild, we went out to the garden to play with them. Suddenly they saw a squirrel and started barking but it didn’t take long. Also, every day at 11 am, the cleaning robot is activated and the dogs run away to the garden because they don’t like the noise (she knows that). We explained this to her and she calmed down, but again, her way of saying things was too demanding and uneducated.

For mental health we tried to forget these events and carry on as normal, although I do not deny that her messages got me down. When we met her in person she gave us the image of being a kind, smiling woman and apparently very relaxed and mature, but her messages showed us a very different face, a dark one. Every day we sent her multiple messages and photos of the dogs to avoid controversy, many of the messages were never answered.

I must mention that during our stay we spent a lot of time cleaning and taking care of the house (more than I thought we would have to do), we worked remotely but we planned very well our agenda to have everything covered, at 10 pm we were in bed feeling exhausted and had almost no time for ourselves.

Anyway, here comes the hard part: The owner arrived a day earlier than expected. We told her it was no problem, we would change the bed so she could sleep well in her room and we would go to the basement. We had to speed up and we cleaned her bedroom, the bathroom, the office, the living room, the couches, the kitchen, we cut the grass, we put a lavender spray on the 3 dogs so they would smell nice, and we bought her a bottle of wine as a welcome. It didn’t take us long to have the house tidy, the next morning it looked like a war field, all the things were on the couches, the table, the kitchen, the floor.

On our last day we went for a walk with her and the 3 dogs to say goodbye while in the evening we cleaned the basement, vacuumed everything and washed the bathroom. We even put the bedding in the washing machine to make it easier for her the next day.

Anyway, our international trip was delayed and we had not internet until late in the night and in that moment we started receiving absurd messages from this woman telling us that we had left the place in terrible conditions, that we were dirty and disrespectful, that she had spent several hours scrubbing every corner with bleach. My jaw dropped just reading the meaningless messages. I told her that I was very surprised by her change of mood but especially by the things she was saying, we had left in very good conditions and a few hours later we received the worst messages, fortunately I took videos of the things in the fridge and how the house was. She never gave us credit for everything we did for the house, for the pets and for her.

For three days in a row she sent us very harassing messages and it really drained our energy. in one she was saying that we shouldn´t have spent time in the basement when she agreed with that when I asked to leave our stuffs there, I don´t understand her. She accused us to stained her kitchen for preparing breakfast, lunch and dinner. How?? Unfortunately the good experience we had had turned dark and miserable.

In the review for her we were thinking of saying very positive things but with these messages I don’t know what to do. Would you write a short and concise honest review of what happened or would you rather leave it without comments?

We will never accept taking care of 6 animals in such a small house. I would not tolerate the level of disorganization and dirt in which the HO left the house, nor the fact that they did not prepare enough space for us to live comfortably for three weeks or that they forced us to sleep with the animals. We are frequent travelers and fortunately we do not use this platform as a way of life, we did sign in to create positive and different experiences because we love dogs and cats but sadly, it turned out to be a horror story.

11 Likes

Please leave a fair and accurate review which deducts stars for cleanliness, accurate description, hospitality, communication etc . This is to warn future sitters . Include all the positives ( pets ? ) .

It’s a blind review meaning owner won’t see it before writing theirs.

Seems likely she is not going to write a :star::star::star::star::star: of you , so not leaving a review at all won’t really serve any purpose as only the hosts voice will be heard .

The THS requirements outlined in the Terms of Service state that the premises must be a clean and hygienic living space. So if it failed to meet this requirement and you have evidence ( photos ) and also for the harassment you have received post sit -
you might decide to raise a member dispute by submitting evidence ( screenshots of messages ) then THS will investigate .

10 Likes

Write a factual review, don’t get personal, stay totally calm, factual, factual, factual, keep each aspect brief and to-the-point. Maintenance things happen so the hot water / clogging is just one of those things that goes wrong from time to time, but as for everything else I really feel for you, that’s terrible.

7 Likes

Totally agree with @Silversitters in that a factual, unemotional review is needed. Future sitters shouldn’t face what you guys have. Great that you have photos & evidence, raise the issues with THS support as a dispute if you want to and screenshot all the abusive messages from the HO (in case she suddenly deletes them as she sounds a bit crazy). Take a deep breath & know you did a good job with happy pets. There are lots of fab sits out there, it was just a duff one this time @Talia #onwardsandupwards

7 Likes

Great input from @Silversitters @HappyDeb and @Cuttlefish

Do leave a correct and factual review. Say the pros and cons and what you would have liked to know pre-sit.

It sounds that she might leave a bad review, it also seems it will be unfair and emotional which will probably emphasize and support the truthfulness of your factual review. The consequence will just as likely be that she will struggle to get sitters rather than you not getting sits.

My regret with reviews is the recommendations I gave that it later proved it was not basis for.

1 Like

Really awful experience, I’m sorry that happened to you.

I would be honest in all aspects of your review. You can’t control what the host may do, but being honest in your review helps you, counters what she may say, gives a heads up to other sitters, and will give you peace of mind that you’ve done the right thing, even if the host has not.

I’m glad you have photos as proof. I always take pictures and/or videos when I arrive and just before I depart. If there are any issues along the way, I document them. I’m trusting, but there are some people who take advantage. Better to avoid a situation where it’s just someone’s word against your own.

Hopefully this sit will soon be a distant memory.

6 Likes

So sorry you went through this, it happened once to me too! With a sit not on the TH platform. I’m not sure what the story is with these people, I have to assume just mental health issues, personality or mood disorders, etc. Maybe it’s a kind of guilt trip to demand more out of the people they bring to the house, I don’t know. Whatever it is, it’s never okay.

When it happened to me I fully realized the vulnerability of being a sitter and having no witnesses or backup, really. Even the TH platform can only do so much. I learned to be pickier about what I get myself into.

Just know that if you’re sure you left the house clean and gave your best then don’t fret too much over it and block her messages. Sometimes you just have to chalk it up and move on instead of getting sucked into truly crazy behavior from others.

I’m sure you’ll have some better sits going forward, partially because certain red flags will trigger you to walk away from some sit applications earlier!

6 Likes

Did not sound that lascivious to me…

More on topic: I always ask where pets sleep. And you could have said no to that herd of pets in the bedroom.

1 Like
  1. If it’s not obvious based on the listing where you’ll sleep, you might ask before accepting.

  2. If sleeping with pets is a dealbreaker for you, definitely ask before accepting.

  3. If someone’s tone makes you uncomfortable, I’d make sure to let them know right off, before they thought it would be OK to continue that way. I’d keep that neutral, like: We don’t know each other well, but I’m feeling uncomfortable about how the tone of this conversation is going.

If they didn’t correct, then I’d escalate a bit. Like: Unfortunately, the tone of our conversations continues to make me feel uncomfortable. I suggest that we wrap up now and try again later.

If they have time to think and don’t correct, depending on the tone, I’d ask whether they might prefer to find another sitter.

  1. If someone implied that maybe I’d broken or damaged something I hadn’t, I’d make sure I started documenting our conversations. Like if we spoke about X in a call, I’d send something like: Following up on the broken X: Since we’ve only just arrived and not put X down the plumbing, I figure you didn’t realize that it was nearly blocked before you left. I’ll be here when you’ve arranged for a plumber. It’s not a major inconvenience to me.

Note: When documenting, keep your tone neutral or friendly and assume you might need to share documentation with THS if things go sideways.

And FWIW, some people unfortunately need to be reminded how to behave or treat others. A firm but polite reply can give fair warning. Bullies or exploiters or rude people sometimes back off when they realize you won’t put up with it. They tend to push or test the waters in various cases, looking for easy marks.

If they can’t correct, then I’d consider leaving by first giving 24 hours notice in writing to them and THS so alternative care can be arranged. And in my review, I’d make clear why I left. Something straightforward, like: Unfortunately, X continued to be rude after I’d asked for a friendlier approach to our discussions. I gave 24 hours notice so they could arrange alternative care. That’s because the way our sit was going, things would likely turn worse, unfortunately.

11 Likes

I am sorry to hear that you have had a bad experience. I am sure the harassing messages in particular were very upsetting. I have never found myself in a similar position so I can’t say for certain how I would handle it.

But in the event, either you or her raise any sort of official dispute, definitely screenshot the messages you have from her showing the inappropriate communication.

If there are things sitters know they wouldn’t want to do, it is really important to see if the sit contains any of these ‘dealbreakers’ before accepting, whether it is having to spend the night with the hosts before they leave for their trip, having animals sleep on the bed, not being able to leave the pets alone for at least X hours,etc… So I think in this regard, this was a good learning experience and will help you vet sits more carefully moving forward.

Another thing I would say is to think back and see if you noticed any red flags prior, if you had any intuitive nudges something was off when reading the listing, communicating initially,etc…

That people felt something was off in some regard but they took the sit anyway because of the dates, to save money, it is somewhere they really wanted to go, wanted to build reviews, they felt ‘bad’ for the host,etc…is a very common theme in ‘bad sit’ stories.

If this was the case for you, this will give you more confidence in trusting your gut moving forward and reducing the risk of bad experiences.

And like many have said, do your best to keep the review factual, free of emotion and as concise as possible, and the same goes for any response to hers.

I know it can be difficult to keep emotion out of it since these bad sits can be a very emotional experience. I know it can be difficult to not offer long explanations and defenses if we are accused of doing things we didn’t do because we think that will help our case with future hosts who may be reviewing our profile. But I think it can actually harm it.

When I see these sorts of really long responses breaking down each and every point, full of emotive language, etc. it gives the impression that perhaps there was some truth to the criticisms. That may or may not be true, but perception is the only thing that matters since the responses are really directed at future people who may be reading the feedback–and have no knowledge of the situation-- not the person who wrote it.

Good luck with whatever happens and I know it can be upsetting now but it will fade!

5 Likes