Sitters Thoughts On Trackers/Health Monitors for Pets

Hi everyone!

I’m very curious to hear from sitters who’ve cared for pets that wear GPS trackers with health/activity monitors. How do you feel about these devices, and do you expect to know about them before the sit? Is it helpful or does it feel overbearing (if you don’t have access to device data)??
My sitters sometimes seem taken aback when they find out during the sit that my dog has an AI-based GPS tracker/health monitor which tells me the following:
Live location everywhere, including in my house
K9 audio monitoring (barking & howling) Can emit sound remotely via the app
Vehicle’s speed (mph) if my dog travels w/ them
Time my dog leaves & returns home
Hours & minutes of sleep
Heart rate & respiratory rate with his overall stress level each day

A former THS sitter once took my dog on a week-long road trip without approval, which I was not okay with. This tracker now allows me to ensure he receives the care requested, and reduces my worries about him. I’ve only explained the device to sitters if asked and have received a couple of forthright opinions, which makes me want to hear from others. ALL experiences and or suggestions ARE WELCOME! Your responses may shape how I handle this topic with future sitters.

Thanks all!

This is sometimes the same substantiation used with outside cameras. IMHO these trackers should be disclosed to sitters in your listing and you make it clear you use the data to “keep an eye” on the sitters/pets activities. I see them as a fundamental lack of trust so wouldn’t accept a sit under those conditions. For the record we also don’t accept sits with external cameras as we have had poor experiences in the past. Edit: Your house your rules.

10 Likes

Gosh…how timely. As a sitter, I was just thinking about posting a similar topic to ask how people feel about this.

Tbh I’m torn. (Full disclosure: I Airtag the pets I sit, as soon as I take responsibility for them.) I’ve had 2 hosts use these gps location/health trackers. Both times I was only told once on site. Only one of those hosts added me to their app account so that I could use it to find the pet if it did an escape-o outside the fenced property (doggo was a sly little mongoose who was known to occasionally go walk-about! :joy:)

I understand POs who want a tool to help track a lost pet, obviously — but I know it can also be a thinly-veiled attempt to keep an eye on their sitter. As a pet owner myself I can understand those desires, even if it rubs me the wrong way not to be trusted or to feel I’m being monitored & tracked. Now I have performance anxiety…did I walk the pets enough for them? Maybe they specified 2 mile walks…will I get docked a star because it was raining one day & we only walked a 1/2 mile? Tractive gives a lot of false positives that the pet left the fenced yard, when it was sitting by my feet in the LR the whole time…is concerned owner going to insist I was negligent & kept letting the pet escape?

So yeah; I don’t have a definitive answer. Even if I believe the hosts have good & valid intentions, it does bug me & it makes me somewhat paranoid…but I also ‘get it.’ So I agree it should be disclosed on the listing, during the pre-sit call, and in the welcome guide so sitters can decide if they are comfortable with it ahead of time.

BUT: as a very conscientious sitter, the first time a host begins second-guessing me & makes it clear they’re really tracking ME vs their pet, I’ll be refusing future sits that use them. :woman_shrugging:

8 Likes

Regardless of sitters or hosts opinions on this forum , monitoring devices that monitor pets inside the home ( e.g this one in OP that provides live location inside the home , audio recording and monitors the pets when sleeping ) are not permitted on a THS sit.

The terms of service state that

5.2.15. follow our Camera and Recording Devices Policy. This includes having no internal recording or monitoring devices enabled during a Sit

With increased popularity of GPS trackers, anirtags and things like Furbo , THS may need to update THS policy to clarify if monitoring of pet while indoors is permitted if it is disclosed in the listing.

10 Likes

I’m not sure that everyone would feel collar-monitors qualify as “internal.” (One host only asked it to be attached during walks…?)

(Nm…somehow missed your last graf :zany_face:)

This is a bit of a can of worms as technically IR motion sensors for standard alarm systems are monitoring devices. Hmmm

I’m currently on a Sit with the cats air tagged and GPS tracked w/ collar, along with the Neighbors’ cats!

In specific, this gated community of Cat carers, have a system setup where the Neighbor releases their cats in the evening and then the other House is notified and has their cats released in the mornings. This system has helped prevent cat break outs and aggression, and has enabled the cats to freely roam the backyard and inner gated community courtyard with low friction.

The Pros..:

On one hand- it’s innovative, where the AI tracking app. will sound a Christmas jingle and Branch, has actually picked up on the GPS Tracking’s sound, and will be notified to / come home.

The app.’s GPS map also has the ability to show you how far the cats are roaming and at what hour they were potentially fence hopping.

The Cons..

As a Sitter and also as someone growing in Animal Knowledge and training, it DOES take a lot of preparation beforehand. And it is Best to have all this communicated and setup for the Sitter beforehand. Aka: have clearly typed instructions, demonstration of how the tracker is charged, what the app. is and how to have that properly setup and installed, when the tracker should be charged and taken off the cat, what routes and areas are okay for the cats and sitter to roam.

My current experience on THS:

When I first arrived to the house, I immediately thought it was ok to take off the tracker cuz I noticed it was not charged.

The home owner immediately panicked and instructed I only take off the tracker when the cats were back home at a certain hour.

I felt some kind of friction in the air as the Neighbor also seemed a bit panicked and was instructing different areas of the house where I should make sure windows are locked so cats wouldn’t slip out.

Overtime- we worked it out.

As someone who has been now growing on her 3rd year in professional pet sitting and also gaining certification in animal knowledge & training., I def. have GRown over time to air on the side of TRUSTING cats to come home. And InSTILLING the *Belief* that if I am building a loving, force-free bond to an animal - it is MUCH more likely to warm up to me- and want to come home.

(Vs. picking up a cat when it clearly looks agitated or forcing a cat to come to you)..

As a sitter, I have witnessed and grown accustomed to both sides of the “Anxious Pet Parent” and the more “Assured/Trusting Pet Parent” - where one is less trusting that their cat will come home and while the other— KNOWS & TRUST that their cat will come back home— and isn’t fretting.

Of course this can only happen, with experience over time. And this goes for the sitter as well.

At my last sit in Orinda— it was proved to me- that when a cat is conditioned to be able to freely roam far— yet still be able to come home to a loving, safe environment- provided with feed, warmth, shelter, and love — it BUILDS their internal & instinctive trust muscle AND adventurous side, as well.

(I was able to walk a cat named Ziggy, offleash and freely, alongside a Senior dog, Roxy). (Isn’t that so Cool?!)

I feel geography also matters a lot here for the safety of certain pets and Pet Parents.

That last sit with Ziggy, Raven, and Roxy had an expansive backyard / nature-like area in the hills of Orinda (we’re talking farmlike areas, lush forest areas, and wine vineyards) vs. at my current sit - in SF - it’s an urban environment with more busy streets, cars, and tourists. There is much less a “free roaming” friendly environment for the cats and for the ease of mind of pet parents.

Def. at the end of day tho— it’s about building bonds with the animals, and with the communication & Trust between home owners and the Sitters - which should happen ideally before, during the meet & greet, and with updates throughout the housesit.

Hope this can help.

And Cheers to the New Year!

2 Likes

We sat for a mini dachshund puppy with a GPS tracker. The welcome guide said just 20 minute walks twice a day which we followed. The owners privately on WhatsApp accused us later after the sit of making the puppy do 2-3 hour walks!! This wasn’t the case as the little mite would have flaked out (obviously!) however we did take him many places with us either being carried in a bag or in a mini trolley… he didn’t like being left at home.

6 Likes

Sometimes you just can’t win. Hopefully they didn’t dock a star over their misconception that you walked the dog too much.

1 Like

Alarm systems are generally only activated when your are outside of the property though.

I’m GenX. This need to know exactly where everyone and everything is at all times is insane to me. Unless there is a medical reason for a pet to have some sort of monitor, I’m against it. But yes - if someone has these it should be disclosed clearly on the profile so only people comfortable with it (or people who don’t read profiles, in which case it’s on them) apply.

I also just learned that you can’t type the acronym F F S on this site :laughing:

8 Likes

Various trackers have been discussed here and elsewhere. The impression I get is that most people would want to know about them in the listing as they would not apply.

My experience is that any monitoring that is available to homeowner makes it too tempting for them to use it to monitor and micromanage the sitter. They just can’t help themselves so it’s best avoided.

8 Likes

I was being a tad pedantic in response to the T&C Edit: I’m not a lawyer.

1 Like

They’d already given us 5* then later checked the gps leading to an exchange via WhatsApp.

1 Like

I appreciate you responding, though your approach and tone don’t align with what I look for in a sitter. Your the type of person I wouldn’t choose to have care for my dog. Your language really speaks for itself. Thanks anyway!

(Edited in line with the Community Rules)

1 Like

Thank you for your thoughts. I’ll keep it in mind.

1 Like

“I’ve only explained the device to sitters if asked and have received a couple of forthright opinions….”
Well that smacks of deceit & a lack of trust. You should be upfront about this tracker. Personally I would not apply, even though I can be trusted to carry out the dog’s routine. I could understand more if you were paying for the service but this is meant to be a mutual exchange.

10 Likes

Agree on needing to abide by THS terms and be transparent from the listing onward. Remember that if you mislead or hide elements that many sitters consider dealbreakers, they might withdraw once they find out. That would potentially mess up your travel plans.

And once a sit starts, even if they quit because of dealbreakers they learn about, sitters are able to write a review. If any review says a host secretly monitored, video’d, tracked, etc., that will likely scare off other sitters, making your membership of questionable value.

8 Likes

I’m not a sitter, I’m an HO

6 Likes

Wow. I think this reply tells us everything :cry:

4 Likes